We Accept Liberty Mutual
And Fight For Your Maximum Payout.
We work directly with Liberty Mutual adjusters to maximize your collision claim, handle all paperwork, and restore your vehicle to factory condition. Nassau County’s certified collision center for over 40 years — we know exactly what your Liberty Mutual policy entitles you to.
You Don’t Have to Use Liberty Mutual’s Repair Network
Liberty Mutual Insurance may recommend their network repair facilities — but New York State law gives you the legal right to choose any licensed body shop. Our I-CAR Gold certified technicians work for you, not your insurer, fighting to maximize your Liberty Mutual payout and fully restore your vehicle.
NY State Law Protects Your Freedom to Choose
You have the legal right to choose any licensed shop — Liberty Mutual’s network recommendations are optional, not mandatory.
We Work for You, Not Liberty Mutual
Our certified team advocates for your maximum coverage — not the minimum payout that protects your insurer’s margin.
40 Years Navigating Insurance Claims
We know Liberty Mutual’s adjuster process and how to document every covered repair to maximize your payout.
Factory Restoration, OEM-Compatible Parts
Every repair meets manufacturer tolerances — protecting your vehicle’s safety systems, performance, and resale value.
Nassau County’s Trusted Liberty Mutual Collision Center
Free Towing to Our Shop
Free 24-hour emergency towing to our Merrick collision center — for all insurance claims.
Call for a tow ›
On-Site Car Rentals
Convenient on-site rental services for all collision repairs.
Get a free estimate ›
We Handle Your Liberty Mutual Claim End-to-End
We contact Liberty Mutual directly, manage your adjuster, file all supplemental claims for covered damage, and handle billing end-to-end. Our experience with Liberty Mutual’s claims process means you get every dollar your policy covers.
Call us before your insurer ›Our Process Is Simple
Call Us Before You File
Tell us what happened before you call Liberty Mutual. We’ll walk you through the process and advise on exactly what your policy should cover — protecting your claim from the start.
We Contact Liberty Mutual For You
We file your claim, manage all adjuster communications, document every covered repair, and fight for your maximum Liberty Mutual payout. You don’t need to make a single call.
Pick Up Your Restored Vehicle
Your vehicle is returned to factory condition — detailed inside and out. We handle final billing directly with Liberty Mutual and keep you updated at every step.
Complete Collision Services — All Covered by Liberty Mutual
From minor fender damage to major structural repairs — every job handled by I-CAR Gold and ASE certified technicians with 40 years of Nassau County experience.
Collision Repair
Full structural and panel repair after any accident — restored to factory specification, covered by your Liberty Mutual policy.
Frame Straightening
Computerized measurement and precision straightening to restore exact factory geometry after any structural impact.
Paint Matching
Computerized color matching on all paint codes — factory-seamless results on every repair, covered by your Liberty Mutual claim.
Dent & Bumper Repair
Expert dent removal and bumper restoration — including paintless dent repair for minor damage eligible under your policy.
Glass Replacement
Windshield and window replacement with OEM-quality glass — often covered by comprehensive coverage in your Liberty Mutual policy.
Full Claim Management
We manage your entire Liberty Mutual claim — adjusters, supplements, and all paperwork handled so you don’t have to.
Liberty Mutual Insurance Collision Repair — FAQ
Answers to the most common questions about using Liberty Mutual Insurance for collision repair at Brookside.
What Our Customers Say
“The recommendation I received for Brookside was so strong I drove an hour each way from Manhattan for an estimate — and it was absolutely worth it. Laura and Paul build immediate trust, and the quality of work and fair pricing delivered exactly that 5-star experience.”
“Paul and Laura worked smoothly with my insurance company and my car now looks better than new! Nothing looks like it was ‘fixed’ — sparkling clean inside and out. Five stars for service, value, quality, and professionalism.”
“Paul and his team rebuilt my car better than before the accident. At pickup they had compounded and waxed the whole car — even areas not involved in the accident. It hasn’t looked this good since the day I drove it off the dealer lot.”
Start Your Liberty Mutual
Claim Today
No obligation. We assess your damage, contact Liberty Mutual on your behalf, and provide a clear estimate — usually same day.
Or call us directly:
(516) 378-9162
Request a Free Estimate
We’ll get back to you within 1 business hour.
We Accept All Major
Insurance Carriers
Beyond Liberty Mutual, we work with every major insurance company in New York. Call us first — we fight for your maximum payout regardless of your carrier.
Don’t see your carrier? Call us — we work with them too.
Call Us First — Before You File Your Claim
Most customers leave money on the table by going through their insurer alone. We contact Liberty Mutual directly, advocate for your maximum payout, and handle all billing — at no extra cost to you.
Call us before your insurer ›Serving All of Nassau County
Brookside Auto Center provides certified collision repair to Liberty Mutual policyholders throughout Nassau County and Long Island, NY — including: